Origin and structure of Athenian democracy

In ancient Greece, the city-states of Athens and Sparta emerged as prominent and influential entities, each characterized by distinctive forms of government and societal structures. Their approaches to governance and citizen participation diverged significantly, with Athens earning renown as the birthplace of democracy, while Sparta adopted an oligarchic system with a strong emphasis on militarism.

In ancient Greece, Athens and Sparta were two prominent city-states with distinct forms of government and social structures. Their approaches to citizen participation and governance differed significantly. Athens is often considered the birthplace of democracy. In the 5th century BCE, the Athenian political system evolved into a form of direct democracy where eligible citizens directly participated in decision-making. In Athens, citizenship was exclusive and based on certain criteria. Only free, adult male citizens who were born to Athenian parents were considered full citizens. Women, slaves, and foreigners were excluded from the political process. The heart of Athenian democracy was the Ekklesia, an assembly of eligible citizens who had the right to propose, discuss, and vote on legislation. Meetings were held regularly, and decisions were made by a majority vote. Some offices, like members of the Council of 500 (Boule), were filled through a lottery system. Citizens were randomly selected to serve for short terms, ensuring a broader participation of the population.

Sparta had an oligarchic form of government, where power was concentrated in the hands of a small group of elite citizens. The Spartan political structure was characterized by a dual monarchy (two kings) and the Gerousia, a council of elders. Spartan citizenship was more broadly distributed than in Athens. Spartan males, known as Spartiates, were considered citizens. However, there were also non-citizen groups, such as the Perioikoi (free non-citizens living in Spartan-controlled areas) and Helots (unfree agricultural laborers). The Gerousia was a council of elders, usually composed of 28 members over the age of 60, plus the two kings. They held significant power, proposing laws and serving as a judicial body. Spartiates underwent rigorous military training from a young age, and their participation in public life was closely tied to their military service. The government emphasized military virtues, and decisions were often influenced by the interests of the military elite.

While both Athens and Sparta had unique ways of organizing their governments, Athens is famous for its direct democracy, with active participation by eligible citizens in decision-making. In contrast, Sparta had an oligarchic structure, and citizenship was tied to military service, with a focus on the warrior class. In Athens, a broader segment of the citizenry had the opportunity to hold public office through a system of elections and lotteries, promoting a more inclusive form of governance. In Sparta, political power was concentrated in the hands of the kings, the Gerousia, and the ephors, with a more restricted role for the general citizen assembly. In both city-states, the rules for selecting public office holders were designed to reflect and reinforce the values and priorities of their respective political systems. Athens aimed for a more inclusive democracy, employing a mix of elections and lotteries, while Sparta had a more stratified system, with hereditary monarchy, a council of elders, and elected officials like the ephors.

While Athens and Sparta were both prominent city-states in ancient Greece, they differed significantly in their governmental structures, but they also shared some similarities. Both Athens and Sparta were Greek city-states (polis) and shared a common cultural and linguistic heritage. The polis was a fundamental political and social unit in ancient Greece. In both city-states, citizenship carried certain privileges and responsibilities. Citizenship was typically limited to free, adult males who met specific criteria. Both Athens and Sparta placed a strong emphasis on military training and service. The Greek city-states were frequently engaged in conflicts with each other and faced external threats, leading to the importance of a strong military. In addition, both Athens and Sparta had an agora, a central marketplace that served as a hub for economic, political, and social activities.

Athens is often hailed as the birthplace of democracy. It developed into a direct democracy, where eligible citizens directly participated in decision-making through the Ekklesia (assembly). Various officials were elected or chosen by lot, and citizens had the opportunity to propose and vote on laws. Sparta had an oligarchic system with elements of monarchy. It had two hereditary kings, a council of elders (Gerousia), and an assembly (Apella). However, the Spartan assembly had less power compared to the Athenian Ekklesia, and the real political influence was concentrated in the hands of a select few. In addition, Athenian citizenship was generally based on descent, and only free, adult males born to Athenian parents were considered full citizens. Women, slaves, and foreigners were excluded from citizenship. Furthermore, Spartan citizenship was more inclusive than Athens. Spartiates were full citizens, but there were also non-citizens like the Perioikoi and Helots, each with different social statuses and rights.

Athens promoted a more individualistic and democratic approach. Citizens were actively involved in decision-making, and personal freedom and expression were valued. Sparta, on the other hand, was more collectivist and focused on the common good. Individual freedoms were often sacrificed for the stability and strength of the state. The emphasis on military training and discipline reflected this collectivist ethos. Athens was a center for culture, philosophy, and the arts. It produced renowned philosophers like Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. The city encouraged intellectual pursuits and cultural achievements. Sparta, while valuing military prowess, did not have the same cultural and intellectual focus. Its society was more conservative and less open to cultural innovation.

To summarize, Athens, in the 5th century BCE, developed into a symbol of democracy where eligible citizens actively engaged in decision-making through the Ekklesia. Citizenship in Athens was exclusive, limited to free, adult males born to Athenian parents, excluding women, slaves, and foreigners. The Athenian democracy centered around the Ekklesia, a participatory assembly where citizens proposed, discussed, and voted on legislation. Key offices were filled through elections and lotteries, promoting a dynamic and inclusive political system. Contrastingly, Sparta adopted an oligarchic structure with a dual monarchy and the Gerousia, a council of elders. Spartan citizenship was more inclusive, encompassing Spartiates as full citizens, alongside non-citizen groups like the Perioikoi and Helots. The Gerousia, composed of elders, held substantial power, proposing laws and serving as a judicial body. Spartan society prioritized military virtues, with Spartiates undergoing rigorous training tied to their participation in public life.

While both city-states shared certain features, such as a focus on military service and citizenship, their differences were profound. Athens embraced democracy, individualism, and cultural achievements, producing renowned philosophers. In contrast, Sparta prioritized an oligarchic system, collective well-being, and a disciplined military ethos, with a more conservative outlook on culture and intellectual pursuits. The contrasting governmental structures and societal values of Athens and Sparta reflect the rich diversity within ancient Greek city-states.

Reference

Athens vs. Sparta in Ancient Greece | history, differences ... - study.com. (n.d.-a). https://study.com/learn/lesson/athens-sparta-differences-life.html 

Democratic elements in the Spartan political structure. (n.d.-b). http://saa.uaic.ro/articles/SAA.22.1.2016.59-76.pdf 

Fad-Admin. (2020, May 28). Individualism in Ancient Greece. Intercollegiate Studies Institute. https://isi.org/intercollegiate-review/individualism-in-ancient-greece/ 

Khan Academy. (n.d.). The Greek Polis (article) | classical Greece. Khan Academy. https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/world-history/ancient-medieval/classical-greece/a/the-greek-polis 

Rothchild, J. A. (2007). Introduction to Athenian Democracy of the Fifth and Fourth Centuries BCE. Wayne State University Law School Research Paper No. 07-32.

Two very different city-states: Sparta and Athens. (n.d.-c). https://www.crf-usa.org/images/t2t/pdf/AthensvSparta.pdf 

What is the difference between the two cities Sparta and Athens in Greece?. Quora. (n.d.). https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-difference-between-the-two-cities-Sparta-and-Athens-in-Greece